Perils of a Critical Mind

“Knowledge is power.”

The more knowledge one acquires; the more power one has in his hand, to critique, criticise or condemn.

As we acquire more knowledge, we tend to test our new-found power on people and issues. In the name of critique (we avoid using the more negative words: criticise or condemn), we tend to use our power to analyse and highlight the imperfection of others. Yet, possessing a critical mind can be perilous. We can become grumpy, cynical and skeptical of everything and everyone that does not match up to our measuring standards. We can easily condemn others even if we can only see what is happening in the foreground, without wanting to first understand the background context.

Perhaps we think that by doing so, we are emulating Jesus who was never afraid or slow to lash out words of rebuke at the wrongdoers. Yet, I sometimes wonder whether we are emulating Jesus or the Pharisees. The Pharisees were equally critical of the people and issues of their days, quick to highlight people and things that did not match up to their measuring standards. The difference between them and Jesus is this: Jesus did it out of love; they did it out of pride and contempt.

Thus, for those of us who possess critical minds; beware of the power that is entrusted to you. Do not be too quick to judge, comment, critique, criticise or condemn. Only be quick in listening, but be very slow in speaking. Speak only when you know that you are truly speaking out of love for the other, not out of pride and contempt to pull down the other. Speak only when you really see the iceberg rather than the tip. Speak not to someone else about it lest you are found guilty of showcasing your critiquing power, but if possible, speak directly to the person involved to benefit him or her with your words of wisdom.

Or else, the power will do no good and can only bring destruction.